Sunday 12 April 2020

Pink Floyd album by album




[A start....] 

Pink Floyd were formed in London in 1965 by four students: Waters, Mason and Wright had enrolled in 1962 at the Regent Street Polytechnic to study architecture, and played together in an adhoc band with fellow students - the band's name evolved through changes from Sigma 6 to the Tea Set. Barrett joined the Tea Set in 1964, later changing the name to Pink Floyd. 

The band moved from psychedelic rock and psychedelic pop through art rock to what many consider  to be prog rock, though essentially they are and have been their own band, creating their own sound and music. The band's creative force in their early days was Sid Barrett, and he remained a significant influence long after he had left the band in 1967 during the initial recording sessions for their second album. Gilmour was brought in as both a support and replacement for Barrett, and is the only personnel change until 1983's Final Cut, which was recorded without Wright who had been fired by Waters during the recording of The Wall. The subsequent three album releases would include Wright, but not Waters who had walked out of the band after Final Cut.  

Wikipedia:

Pink Floyd were an English rock band formed in London in 1965. Gaining a following as a psychedelic rock group, they were distinguished for their extended compositions, sonic experimentation, philosophical lyrics and elaborate live shows, and became a leading band of the progressive rock genre. They are one of the most commercially successful and influential bands in popular music history.
Pink Floyd were founded by students Syd Barrett (guitar, lead vocals), Nick Mason (drums), Roger Waters (bass guitar, vocals), and Richard Wright (keyboards, vocals). Under Barrett's leadership, they released two charting singles and a successful debut album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967). Guitarist and vocalist David Gilmour joined in December 1967; Barrett left in April 1968 due to deteriorating mental health. Waters became the primary lyricist and thematic leader, devising the concepts behind the albums The Dark Side of the Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977), The Wall (1979), and The Final Cut (1983). The band also composed several film scores.
Following personal tensions, Wright left Pink Floyd in 1979, followed by Waters in 1985. Gilmour and Mason continued as Pink Floyd, rejoined later by Wright. The three produced two more albums—A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987) and The Division Bell (1994)—and toured both albums before entering a long period of inactivity. In 2005, all but Barrett reunited for a one-off performance at the global awareness event Live 8. Barrett died in 2006, and Wright in 2008. The last Pink Floyd studio album, The Endless River (2014), was based on unreleased material from the Division Bell recording sessions.
Pink Floyd were one of the first British psychedelia groups, and are credited with influencing genres such as progressive rock and ambient music. Four albums topped US or UK record charts; the songs "See Emily Play" (1967) and "Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2" (1979) were their only top 10 singles in either territory. The band were inducted into the US Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1996 and the UK Music Hall of Fame in 2005. By 2013, they had sold more than 250 million records worldwide, with The Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall two of the best-selling albums of all time.


AllMusic:

Some bands turn into shorthand for a certain sound or style, and Pink Floyd belongs among that elite group. The very name connotes something specific: an elastic, echoing, mind-bending sound that evokes the chasms of space. Pink Floyd grounded that limitless sound with exacting explorations of mundane matters of ego, mind, memory, and heart, touching upon madness, alienation, narcissism, and society on their concept albums of the '70s. Of these concept albums, Dark Side of the Moon resonated strongest, earning new audiences year after year, decade after decade, and its longevity makes sense. That 1973 album distilled the wild psychedelia of their early years -- that brief, heady period when they were fronted by Syd Barrett -- into a slow, sculpted, widescreen epic masterminded by Roger Waters, the bassist who was the band's de facto leader in the '70s. Waters fueled the band's golden years, conceiving such epics as Wish You Were Here and The Wall, but the band survived his departure in the '80s, with guitarist David Gilmour stepping to the forefront on A Momentary Lapse of Reason and The Division Bell. Throughout the years, drummer Nick Mason and keyboardist Rick Wright appeared in some capacity, and the band's sonic signature was always evident: a wide, expansive sound that was instantly recognizable as their own, yet was adopted by all manner of bands, from guitar-worshiping metalheads to freaky, hippie, ambient electronic duos. Unlike almost any of their peers, Pink Floyd played to both sides of the aisle: they were rooted in the blues but their heart belonged to the future, a dichotomy that made them a quintessentially modern 20th century band.


First recordings and releases


The Early Years 1965-1967 (2016)

The really early stuff from 1965, when they were called The Tea Set and Bob Klose was in the band, is British RnB (with a distinct Boo Didley sound), which is not surprising considering the material was written and recorded in 1964/1965, the period of Five Live Yardbirds, The Angry Young ThemMy Generation, and Kinks. By 1966 Klose had left, they had changed their name to Pink Floyd, and what we hear is proper Pink Floyd. 

All songs written by Barrett, except where noted.

1965 recordings :

  1. "Lucy Leave" – 2:57
  2. "Double O Bo" – 2:57
  3. "Remember Me" – 2:46
  4. "Walk with Me Sydney" (Roger Waters) – 3:11
  5. "Butterfly" – 3:00
  6. "I'm a King Bee" (Slim Harpo) – 3:13

1966–1967 recordings:

  1. "Arnold Layne" (single mix) – 2:57
  2. "See Emily Play" (single mix) – 2:55
  3. "Apples and Oranges" (single mix) – 3:05
  4. "Candy and a Currant Bun" (single mix) – 2:45
  5. "Paintbox" (single mix) – 3:48
  6. "Matilda Mother" (alternate version) (2010 mix) – 4:01
  7. "Jugband Blues" (2010 mix) – 3:01
  8. "In the Beechwoods" (instrumental) (2010 mix) – 4:43
  9. "Vegetable Man" (2010 mix) – 2:32
  10. "Scream Thy Last Scream" (2010 mix) – 4:43







"Arnold Layne" (March 1967)


First official Pink Floyd release is this non-album single, which came backed with "Candy And A Currant Bun".  "Arnold Layne" is a classic. It reached 20 in the charts. 

Wikipedia
Score: 7 


"See Emily Play" (June 1967) 

Second single was even more successful, reaching No. 6. B-side was "The Scarecrow".  

Wikipedia
Score: 8

Albums

The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (Aug 1967)

Fascinating debut. Edgy, quirky, interesting psychedelic material. Crackling guitar work. This is the most innovative, most exciting, most way out album the group ever recorded. This is pure Syd Barrett. Barrett was interested in Keith Rowe's band AMM who released their first album, AMMMusic, in 1966, and some elements of AMM appear in "Interstellar Overdrive".  


Released5 August 1967
Recorded21 February – 21 May 1967
StudioEMI, London
Genre
Length41:54[3]
LabelEMI Columbia
ProducerNorman Smith

All tracks are written by Syd Barrett unless otherwise noted.

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Astronomy Dominé" Barrett and Richard Wright4:12
2."Lucifer Sam" Barrett3:07
3."Matilda Mother" Wright and Barrett3:08
4."Flaming" Barrett2:46
5."Pow R. Toc H."
oral sounds by Barrett, Waters and Wright4:26
6."Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk"WatersWaters3:05
Total length:20:44
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Interstellar Overdrive"
  • Barrett,
  • Waters,
  • Wright, 
  • Mason
instrumental9:41
2."The Gnome" Barrett2:13
3."Chapter 24" Barrett3:42
4."The Scarecrow" Barrett2:11
5."Bike" Barrett3:21
Total length:21:08


AllMusic: 10 
Score: 10




 




  
Speak (Oct 1967)
(Soundtrack)

Soundtrack recorded for John Latham's 1962 film Speak.  The film consists of a continuous series of simple colour designs (or abstract paintings), all based on a circular pattern. The music is almost random pluckings and scrapings and doodles and keyboard chords, though has a primitive ambient feel. There is the sense that the band didn't give much time to this, and Latham rejected the band's offering, preferring to continue to use the sound of circular saws, which does feel more appropriate given the circular imagery.



"Apples and Oranges" (Nov 1967)

The band mimed "Apples and Oranges" on American TV. All the band look a little awkward and shy, while Syd looks like a rock god, but also completely stressed and out of it. The American tour did not go well for Syd. The song is quirky, but not entirely successful.  It reached 55 in the chart. B side was "Paint Box". The promo video shows Gilmore miming on guitar, though Barrett had played  guitar on the recording, and was still officially in the band, though unreliable. 

Wikipedia
Score: 4


"It Would Be So Nice"  (April 1968)
"Julia Dream"



 

(The Look of the Week, May 1967)


A Saucerful of Secrets (June 1968)

During the recording of their second album the band became concerned at Barrett's increasing odd behaviour and drafted in Barrett's Cambridge friend Dave Gilmour to both support and replace him. This is the only album on which all five members appear, but they only play together on one track, "Set The Controls For The Heart of The Sun" in which Gilmour and Barrett both play minor guitar parts.  Barrett only plays guitar on three tracks, and only wrote one, "Jugband Blues", which is also the only one on which he sings. It's a decent album, and "Set The Controls" is a good track, but this is not the same band, driven by Barrett, who created the weird and wonderful Piper.


Released29 June 1968
Recorded9 May 1967 – 3 May 1968
Studio
Genre
Length39:25
LabelEMI Columbia
ProducerNorman Smith

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Let There Be More Light"WatersWright and Gilmour5:38
2."Remember a Day"WrightWright4:33
3."Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun"WatersWaters5:28
4."Corporal Clegg"WatersGilmour, Mason and Wright4:13
Total length:19:52
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."A Saucerful of Secrets"
  • I. "Something Else" (3:57)
  • II. "Syncopated Pandemonium" (3:07)
  • III. "Storm Signal" (1:34)
  • IV. "Celestial Voices" (3:19)
Wright, Mason, Gilmour, Watersoral sounds by Gilmour and Wright11:57
2."See-Saw"WrightWright4:36
3."Jugband Blues"Syd BarrettBarrett3:00
Total length:19:33
  • Roger Waters – bass guitar, percussion (3, 5), vocals
  • Richard Wright – keyboards, vocals
  • David Gilmour – guitars (all except 2 and 7),  vocals
  • Nick Mason – drums (all except 2), percussion, vocals (4)
  • Syd Barrett – vocals (7), slide guitar (2), acoustic guitar (2, 7), electric guitar (3, 7)

AllMusic: 7 
Score: 6 

"Point Me At The Sky" (Dec 1968)

The B-side was "Careful with That Axe, Eugene"


Wikipedia
Score:

More (1969)

The album consists of the music the band wrote for the film More. The band have found their feet after letting Barrett go. It's a minor album, but very good. It is sadly overlooked. It's a bit random, but there are some good songs here, and an early example of heavy metal in "The Nile Song".


Released13 June 1969[
RecordedJanuary – February 1969
StudioPye, London
Genre
Length44:57
LabelEMI Columbia
ProducerPink Floyd

All tracks are written by Roger WatersRichard WrightDavid Gilmour and Nick Mason, except where noted.

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Cirrus Minor"Waters5:18
2."The Nile Song"Waters3:26
3."Crying Song"Waters3:33
4."Up the Khyber"MasonWright2:12
5."Green Is the Colour"Waters2:58
6."Cymbaline"Waters4:50
7."Party Sequence" 1:07
Total length:23:24
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Main Theme" 5:27
2."Ibiza Bar" 3:19
3."More Blues" 2:12
4."Quicksilver" 7:13
5."A Spanish Piece"Gilmour1:05
6."Dramatic Theme" 2:15
Total length:21:32


AllMusic: 6 
Score: 7

Ummagumma (1969)

I recall a lot of people in the early Seventies had this album. It is a double album. The first disc is live, with two long tracks on each side. All the tracks had been previously released, though "Careful With That Axe, Eugene", had not appeared on an album - it had been the b-side of the unsuccessful single "Point Me At The Sky".  The live album is the best disc. The other disc contains largely failed studio experiments by the four individual members of the band. Most people played that disc only once or twice, but somehow it got talked about a lot.

Released7 November 1969
Recorded27 April and 2 May 1969 (live album)
Venue
StudioAbbey Road, London
Genre
Length
  • 86:32 (in total)
  • 39:36 (live album)
  • 46:56 (studio album)
LabelHarvest
Producer

Record one – live album
Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Astronomy Domine"Syd BarrettGilmour, Waters, Wright8:32
2."Careful with That Axe, Eugene"Waters (whispered phrase, screaming) and Gilmour (scat singing)8:49
Total length:17:21
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun"WatersWaters9:27
2."A Saucerful of Secrets"
  • Waters,
  • Wright,
  • Mason,
  • Gilmour
Gilmour (wordless vocals)12:48
Total length:22:15
Record two – studio album
Side three
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Sysyphus – (Parts 1–4)"Wrightinstrumental13:28
2."Grantchester Meadows"WatersWaters7:26
3."Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict"WatersWaters (vocalizations)4:59
Total length:25:53
Side four
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."The Narrow Way – (Parts 1–3)"GilmourGilmour12:17
2."The Grand Vizier's Garden Party (Part 1: Entrance; Part 2: Entertainment; Part 3: Exit)"Masoninstrumental8:46
Total length:21:03


Score: 5 

 
Syd Barrett
The Madcap Laughs (Jan 1970) 

Barrett's debut solo album has always had the reputation of being a masterpiece, that I have never quite understood. I am a fan of the second album, but this one - especially the awful Gilmour and Waters produced tracks - sounds like stuff that should never have been released. The songs are poor, undeveloped, often simplistic and ugly (perhaps deliberately so, given Barrett's uncooperative state of mind at the time) - they lack the charm of his best songs; and the performances are heavy, clumsy, and sometimes simply downright bad. 

The back cover has a photo that includes a nude woman - she is Evelyn "Iggy" Rose, Barrett's then live-in girlfriend. 



Released3 January 1970
Recorded28 May 1968 – 5 August 1969
StudioAbbey Road, London
Genre
Length37:41
LabelHarvest
Producer

Side one
No.TitleNotesLength
1."Terrapin"
  • Take 1, recorded 11 April 1969, overdubs added 4 May
5:04
2."No Good Trying"
  • Take 3, recorded 11 April 1969, overdubs added 3–4 May
3:26
3."Love You"
  • Take 4, recorded 11 April 1969, overdubs added 3 May
2:30
4."No Man's Land"
  • Take 5, recorded 17 April 1969, overdubs added 4 May
3:03
5."Dark Globe"
  • Take 1, recorded 5 August 1969
  • Produced by Gilmour and Waters
2:02
6."Here I Go"
  • Take 5, recorded 17 April 1969
3:11
Side two
No.TitleNotesLength
7."Octopus"
  • Take 11, recorded 12 June 1969, overdubs added 13 June
  • Produced by Barrett and Gilmour
3:47
8."Golden Hair"
  • Take 11, recorded 12 June 1969
  • Produced by Barrett and Gilmour
1:59
9."Long Gone"
  • Take 1, recorded 26 July 1969
  • Produced by Gilmour and Waters
2:50
10."She Took a Long Cold Look"
  • Take 5, recorded 26 July 1969
  • Produced by Gilmour and Waters
1:55
11."Feel"
  • Take 1, recorded 26 July 1969
  • Produced by Gilmour and Waters
2:17
12."If It's in You"
  • Take 5, recorded 26 July 1969
  • Produced by David Gilmour and Roger Waters
2:26
13."Late Night"
  • Take 2, recorded 28 May 1968, overdubs added 11 April 1969
  • Produced by Pete Jenner, Malcolm Jones (overdubs)
3:10
Total length:37:47


Score: 5 

Atom Heart Mother (Oct 1970)

A big selling album - another one that everyone seemed to have, but nobody played it much after the first time. Repeated listening will make it more familiar and acceptable, though hardly fascinating or exciting. The band created a long instrumental suite that filled side one. But it doesn't work. And they tried the Ummagumma idea again of everyone writing one song each for the second side, which simply results in more throwaway stuff. The most interesting and memorable track is the last one "Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast", which is whimsical and throwaway, though does catch the attention; however,  that's not enough to save the album.  File under mostly boring.   


Released2 October 1970
RecordedMarch – August 1970
StudioAbbey Road, London
Genre
Length52:06
LabelHarvest
Producer

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Atom Heart Mother"
I. "Father's Shout"
II. "Breast Milky"
III. "Mother Fore"
IV. "Funky Dung"
V. "Mind Your Throats Please"
VI. "Remergence"
23:44
2:50
2:33
4:50
5:15
2:28
5:48
Total length:23:44
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
2."If"WatersWaters4:31
3."Summer '68"WrightWright5:29
4."Fat Old Sun"GilmourGilmour5:22
5."Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast"
I. "Rise and Shine"
II. "Sunny Side Up"
III. "Morning Glory"
  • Waters, 
  • Mason, 
  • Gilmour, 
  • Wright
Instrumental, speech by Alan Styles13:00
Total length:28:22


Score: 3 

 
Syd Barrett
Barrett (Nov 1970) 


Barrett's second solo album had a smoother genesis, and we find here the sort of songs and performances that we hoped to find on The Madcap Laughs - songs that are light, quirky, original, amusing, poetic and charming. Perhaps not towering works of genius, but certainly inventive and sparkling. The production and performance, this time, is professional. Sadly this album gets overlooked for the more shocking and clumsy Madcap


Released14 November 1970
Recorded26 February – 21 July 1970
StudioAbbey Road, London
GenrePsychedelic folk[1]
Length38:43
LabelHarvest
Producer

Side one
No.TitleNotesLength
1."Baby Lemonade"Take 1, recorded 26 February 19704:10
2."Love Song"Take 1, recorded 14 July 1970, overdubs added 17 July3:03
3."Dominoes"Take 3, recorded 14 July 19704:08
4."It Is Obvious"Take 1, recorded 17 July 1970, overdubs added 20 July2:59
5."Rats"Demo, recorded 7 May 1970, overdubs added 5 June3:00
6."Maisie"Take 2, recorded 26 February 19702:51
Side two
No.TitleNotesLength
7."Gigolo Aunt"Take 15, recorded 27 February 1970, overdubs added 2 April5:46
8."Waving My Arms in the Air/I Never Lied to You"Take 1, recorded 27 February 1970, overdubs and new vocal track 2 April3:59
9."Wined and Dined"Take 10, recorded 14 July 19702:58
10."Wolfpack"Take 2, recorded 3 April 19703:41
11."Effervescing Elephant"Take 9, recorded 14 July 19701:52
Total length:38:43


Score: 8  


Relics (May 1971)

Compilation album. A useful and attractive collection of tracks from the period of the first three albums, includes some singles and b-sides that didn't appear on the albums, plus an unreleased track, so worth getting. More than just a compilation album. The tracks are very good - and the album as a whole is more attractive, powerful, and interesting than  the "proper" albums released either side of it. I recall that most people had this in their collection, and it got played a lot. 


Released14 May 1971 (UK)
Recorded1967–1969
Genre
Length49:38
LanguageEnglish
LabelStarline
ProducerPink Floyd, Norman Smith
Joe Boyd


Side one[edit]

No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Arnold Layne" (Single March 1967)BarrettBarrett2:56
2."Interstellar Overdrive" (from The Piper at the Gates of Dawn 1967)Barrett, WatersWrightMasoninstrumental9:43
3."See Emily Play" (Single June 1967)BarrettBarrett2:53
4."Remember a Day" (from A Saucerful of Secrets 1968)WrightWright4:29
5."Paint Box" (B-side to "Apples and Oranges" November 1967)WrightWright3:33
Total length:23:34

Side two[edit]

No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
6."Julia Dream" (B-side to "It Would Be So Nice", April 1968)WatersGilmour2:37
7."Careful with That Axe, Eugene" (B-side to "Point Me at the Sky", December 1968)Gilmour, Waters, Wright, Masoninstrumental, vocalizations by Waters and Gilmour5:45
8."Cirrus Minor" (from Soundtrack from the Film More 1969)WatersGilmour5:18
9."The Nile Song" (from Soundtrack from the Film More 1969)WatersGilmour3:25
10."Biding My Time" (Previously unreleased, 1969)WatersWaters5:18
11."Bike" (from The Piper at the Gates of Dawn 1967)BarrettBarrett3:21
Total length:25:44


Wikipedia
AllMusic: 9 
Score: 7 


Meddle (Oct 1971)

This is good stuff. It consolidates what Floyd have done so far, so carries echoes of that - there's songs that could have appeared on More (1969) or Atom Heart (1970) or Saucer (1968) or even Piper (1967) and songs that project into what they will do in the future and could have appeared on Obscured (1972) or Dark Side (1973). A transitional album, but also Floyd at their best when the whole band work together, as on "Echoes" and "One Of These Days". 


Released30 October 1971
RecordedJanuary–August 1971
StudioAIRAbbey Road, and Morgan in London
GenreArt rock
Length46:48
LabelHarvest
ProducerPink Floyd

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."One of These Days"
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Mason
instrumental 5:57
2."A Pillow of Winds"
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
Gilmour5:13
3."Fearless" (including "You'll Never Walk Alone")
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
(including RodgersHammerstein II)
Gilmour6:08
4."San Tropez"WatersWaters3:44
5."Seamus"
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Mason
Gilmour2:15
Total length:23:17
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Echoes"
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Gilmour
  • Mason
Gilmour and Wright23:31
Total length:23:31


Score: 7  

Obscured by Clouds (June 1972)

Another soundtrack album in the style of More (1969), but not as varied, interesting or attractive. The material is quite light, fairly conventional, and was created quickly. It is generally poorly regarded by the public, though highly regarded by some Floyd fans. The band were starting work on Dark Side, and wanted to keep their energy and creativity for that album. The soundtrack is for the film La Vallee (1972). 

Released2 June 1972[1]
Recorded23 February – 6 April 1972
Studio
GenreRock 
Length40:08
LabelHarvest
ProducerPink Floyd

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Obscured by Clouds"David GilmourRoger WatersInstrumental3:03
2."When You're In"Gilmour, Waters, Richard WrightNick MasonInstrumental2:18
3."Burning Bridges"Wright, WatersGilmour, Wright3:29
4."The Gold It's in the..."Gilmour, WatersGilmour3:07
5."Wot's... Uh the Deal?"Gilmour, WatersGilmour5:08
6."Mudmen"Wright, GilmourInstrumental4:20
Total length:21:25
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Childhood's End"GilmourGilmour4:31
2."Free Four"WatersWaters4:15
3."Stay"Wright, WatersWright4:05
4."Absolutely Curtains"Gilmour, Waters, Wright, MasonInstrumental5:52
Total length:18:43



Score: 3 


  
Film


Originally simply titled "Pink Floyd", it has since become known as "Live at Pompeii"; this is a "live" recording of Pink Floyd playing in an empty arena in Pompeii. 

It's not a concert, it's just the band being filmed playing some tracks - and they sound pretty much as they do on the original albums. They are different of course, but there is little creativity added to them, and there is no audience atmosphere. This is not Bob Marley live at the Lyceum. Consider these tracks as alternative takes. Some fans like these takes more than the originals - fair does, each to their own. But not for me. 

Directed byAdrian Maben
StarringPink Floyd
Cinematography
Edited byJosé Pinheiro
Music byPink Floyd
Distributed byPolyGram Music Video (1983–1999)
Universal Pictures (1999–present)
Release date
  • 2 September 1972
Running time
64 minutes



Score:  3 



This album is in a class of its own. Totally extraordinary. This is Pink Floyd's peak, and though it is essentially based on the music ideas introduced on the first album by Syd Barret, it is also the culmination of the development of those ideas by the band over the years since Barret left, and the band needed those years to arrive at the point where they felt confident enough to deliver something as bold, rich, and balanced as this. Overall, the musical ideas and motifs in this album are not unique - many of the sounds the band themselves had tried out previously, and others were already out there, especially in the early years of the Seventies, when the album was recorded. But somehow, the sounds and ideas in this album coalesce less as an experiment in  sound and musical ideas, and more as a designed achievement - each song leading to the next as part of a planned progression of an overall structure like a symphony.  Though all lyrics are by Waters, the music and the structure of the album was a collaborative experience, including the contributions of engineer Alan Parsons (of the Alan Parsons Project) and vocalist Clare Torry. 


Released1 March 1973
Recorded31 May 1972 – 9 February 1973
StudioAbbey Road, London
Genre
Length43:09
Label
ProducerPink Floyd

All lyrics are written by Roger Waters.[162]

Side one
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Speak to Me"Masoninstrumental1:05
2."Breathe" (In the Air)Gilmour2:49
3."On the Run"
  • Waters, 
  • Gilmour
instrumental3:45
4."Time"
  • Waters, 
  • Gilmour, 
  • Wright, 
  • Mason
  • Gilmour 
  • Wright
6:53
5."The Great Gig in the Sky"
Torry4:43
Total length:19:15
Side two
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
6."Money"WatersGilmour6:22
7."Us and Them"
  • Wright
Gilmour7:49
8."Any Colour You Like"
  • Gilmour, 
  • Mason, 
  • Wright
instrumental3:26
9."Brain Damage"WatersWaters3:46
10."Eclipse"WatersWaters2:12
Total length:23:35


AllMusic: 10 
Score: 10 

A very assured and mature album, continuing the influence of Barrett that had brought them so far, and to whom the album is clearly dedicated in "Crazy Diamond", and the title song. Dark Side marked a transition in the band, and this demonstrated what they had become and the possibility of what they could remain. However....


Released12 September 1975
Recorded13 January – 28 July 1975[1]
StudioAbbey Road, London
Genre
Length44:11
LabelHarvest (UK)
Columbia (US)
ProducerPink Floyd

All lyrics are written by Roger Waters.

Side one
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (Parts I–V)Waters13:32
2."Welcome to the Machine"WatersGilmour7:28
Total length:21:00
Side two
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Have a Cigar" (featuring Roy Harper)WatersHarper5:08
2."Wish You Were Here"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
Gilmour5:35
3."Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (Parts VI–IX)
  • Wright 
  • Gilmour 
  • Waters
  • (Parts VI–VIII)
    Wright (Part IX)
Waters12:28
Total length:23:11

Score: 8

Animals (1977)

Gilmour, Mason and Wright were distracted or dispirited during the recording of this album, and it become dominated by Waters who does the bulk of the writing and the singing. It is a very weak album. Waters does not have an attractive singing voice, and he is limited in what he can do with it. The music retreats into plodding prog rock, and is the least interesting and forward looking of all Floyd's albums. This is 1977, but this could come from the early Seventies - there are similarities with Aqualung (1971). The only saving grace is Gilmour's guitar work, particularly on Dogs. On the whole a tedious, pretentious and fairly crappy prog rock album that is the opposite of the Floyd of Syd Barrett.  This marks the start of the Roger Waters period, which is more about Rogers Waters than Pink Floyd. 

The album is very popular with Floyd fans - especially those who like the later Floyd, and those who like Gilmour's guitar playing.  I find it limited and somewhat boring. 

Released23 January 1977
RecordedApril – December 1976
StudioBritannia Row, London
GenreProgressive rock[1]
Length41:40
LabelHarvest
ProducerPink Floyd

All tracks written and all lead vocals performed by Roger Waters, except where noted.

Side one
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Pigs on the Wing (Part One)"  1:24
2."Dogs"
  • Gilmour 
  • Waters
17:04
Total length:18:28
Side two
No.TitleLength
1 (3)."Pigs (Three Different Ones)"11:28
2 (4)."Sheep"10:20
3 (5)."Pigs on the Wing (Part Two)"1:24
Total length:23:12

  • David Gilmour – lead vocals (2), lead guitar (2–4), bass guitar (3, 4), acoustic guitar (2)
  • Roger Waters – lead vocals (all tracks), acoustic guitar (1, 5), rhythm guitar (3, 4), bass guitar (2)
  • Nick Mason – drums
  • Richard Wright – keyboards 

Score: 3

 
David Gilmour
David Gilmour (1978) 

Gilmour's first solo album is a quiet, simple, low key affair. The guitar solos feel overdone on the rather pedestrian songs. It's all soft and pleasant, touching on folk pop with a touch of blues, and then comes an ornate out of place Floydish guitar solo. The lack of ambition AND the lack of feel here has surprised me. I thought I would like this more than Waters' debut solo, but that is not the case.  I like the album, but it's not significant or memorable. "My Way" has a good vibe, there is a JJ Cale feel about this track. 


Released26 May 1978
RecordedFebruary–March 1978
StudioSuper Bear Studios, France
Genre
Length46:19
Label
ProducerDavid Gilmour

All music composed by David Gilmour except "There's No Way Out of Here" written by Ken Baker. All lyrics by Gilmour, except where noted.

Side one
No.TitleLyricsLength
1."Mihalis"[instrumental]5:46
2."There's No Way Out of Here"Ken Baker5:08
3."Cry from the Street"Gilmour, Eric Stewart5:13
4."So Far Away" 5:50
Total length:21:57
Side two
No.TitleLyricsLength
5."Short and Sweet"Gilmour, Roy Harper5:30
6."Raise My Rent"[instrumental]5:33
7."No Way" 5:32
8."It's Deafinitely"[instrumental]4:27
9."I Can't Breathe Anymore" 3:04
Total length:24:06


Score: 3 


The Wall (1979)

A tedious concept album in the style of Tommy (1969). Hugely popular partly due to the big success of "Another Brick In The Wall". Waters appears to have treated everyone in a really egotistic and shitty manner, refusing to officially or financially acknowledge the creative contributions of the producer, and then mocking him for it, and forcing Wright to resign from the band and play as a session musician.  Other than a few tracks such as "Another Brick" and "Comfortably Numb" I find most of this album unlistenable shit.

Released30 November 1979
RecordedDecember 1978 – November 1979
Studio
Genre
Length81:08
Label
Producer

All tracks written by Roger Waters, except where noted.

Side one
No.TitleLead vocalsLength
1."In the Flesh?"Waters3:16
2."The Thin Ice"
2:27
3."Another Brick in the Wall, Part 1"Waters3:11
4."The Happiest Days of Our Lives"Waters1:46
5."Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
3:59
6."Mother"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
5:32
Total length:20:11
Side two
No.TitleLead vocalsLength
1."Goodbye Blue Sky"Gilmour2:45
2."Empty Spaces"Waters2:10
3."Young Lust" (writers: Waters, Gilmour)Gilmour3:25
4."One of My Turns"Waters3:41
5."Don't Leave Me Now"Waters4:08
6."Another Brick in the Wall, Part 3"Waters1:18
7."Goodbye Cruel World"Waters1:16
Total length:18:43 
Side three
No.TitleLead vocalsLength
1."Hey You"
  • Gilmour 
  • Waters
4:40
2."Is There Anybody Out There?"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
2:44
3."Nobody Home"Waters3:26
4."Vera"Waters1:35
5."Bring the Boys Back Home"Waters1:21
6."Comfortably Numb" (writers: Gilmour, Waters)
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
6:23
Total length:20:09
Side four
No.TitleLead vocalsLength
1."The Show Must Go On"Gilmour1:36
2."In the Flesh"Waters4:15
3."Run Like Hell" (writers: Gilmour, Waters)Waters4:20
4."Waiting for the Worms"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
4:04
5."Stop"Waters0:30
6."The Trial" (writers: Waters, Bob Ezrin)Waters5:13
7."Outside the Wall"Waters1:41
Total length:21:39  (80:39)


Score: 3 1/2

 
Nick Mason
Nick Mason's Fictitious Sports (May 1981)

Mason's first solo album; written by Carla Bley, it sounds like a Carla Bley album.  


Released3 May 1981[1]
Recordedin October 1979, at Grog Kill Studios, Willow, New York by Michael Mantler, assisted by Nick Mason; mixed in December 1979 & May 1980 at Village Recorders & the Producer's Workshop, L.A. by James Guthrie
GenreJazz-rockprogressive rockCanterbury sound
Length36:15
LabelHarvest (UK)
Columbia (US)
Producer

All songs written by Carla Bley.

Side one[edit]

  1. "Can't Get My Motor to Start" – 3:39
  2. "I Was Wrong" – 4:12
  3. "Siam" – 4:48
  4. "Hot River" – 5:16

Side two[edit]

  1. "Boo to You Too" – 3:26
  2. "Do Ya?" – 4:36
  3. "Wervin'" – 3:58
  4. "I'm a Mineralist" – 6:16


AllMusic: 
Score: 

Compilation album of  tracks from the band's 1970s albums, with "Money" entirely re-recorded by Gilmore in 1981, and "Shine" and "Brick" being alternative mixes. It doesn't work for me. 


Side One
No.TitleWriter(s)Original albumLength
1."One of These Days"Meddle5:50
2."Money" (Re-recorded in 1981 at New Roydonia Studios)WatersThe Dark Side of the Moon6:46
3."Sheep"WatersAnimals10:25
Total length:23:01
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Original albumLength
1."Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (edit)
  • Gilmour 
  • Waters 
  • Wright
Wish You Were Here10:41
2."Wish You Were Here"
  • Waters 
  • Gilmour
Wish You Were Here5:26
3."Another Brick in the Wall (Part II)" (edit)WatersThe Wall3:53
Total length:20:00


Score: 4 



"When the Tigers Broke Free" (July 1982 - added to The Final Cut in 2004)
"Bring the Boys Back Home" (alternative version)



The Final Cut (1983)

Self-indulgence to the hilt. Waters has got ideas, but also more ego than talent. The band are reduced to Waters, Gilmour and Mason, and by the end of this recording, Waters, who treats Mason and Gilmour as session musicians, leaves the band and insists that Pink Floyd are over. But Gilmour and Mason fight to keep the name, and bring back Wright, and Pink Floyd continues. For all the tension and unpleasantness, this is not a successful album. It is not a pleasant listen. 

Released21 March 1983
RecordedJuly–December 1982
Studio
Genre
Length43:14
LabelHarvest
Producer

All tracks are written by Roger Waters.

No.TitleLength
1."The Post War Dream"3:02
2."Your Possible Pasts"4:22
3."One of the Few"1:23
4."The Hero's Return"2:56
5."The Gunner's Dream"5:07
6."Paranoid Eyes"3:40
7."Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert"1:19
8."The Fletcher Memorial Home"4:11
9."Southampton Dock"2:13
10."The Final Cut"4:46
11."Not Now John"5:01
12."Two Suns in the Sunset"5:14


Score: 2

 
David Gilmour 
About Face (March 1984)

Gilmour's second solo album, released a few weeks before Roger Waters' first solo album. The tensions that had mounted up in the band with Waters' arrogant and egocentric and bullying behaviour led to Waters flouncing off, and announcing that the band had broken up, while he got on with his solo album. Gilmour stood up to Waters, and fought him in court for the right to keep the band alive, and he brought out his solo album with it's cover image of him in a telling image which is suggestive of a hitch-hiking gesture, also a get lost gesture, and a that's in the past gesture. Waters had accused the others of not pulling their weight creatively. This is Gilmore's response - an album packed with solid songs, solidly performed. The overall impression, however, is of a decent, solid album that, despite critical praise, doesn't quite impress or excite. 


Released5 March 1984
Recorded1983
StudioPathé Marconi, Paris; 
Abbey Road Studios;
mixed at Mayfair Studios
Genre
Length45:18
Label
Producer

All lyrics are written by David Gilmour, except where noted; all music is composed by David Gilmour.

Side one
No.TitleLyricsLength
1."Until We Sleep" 5:15
2."Murder" 4:59
3."Love on the Air"Pete Townshend4:19
4."Blue Light" 4:35
5."Out of the Blue" 3:35
Side two
No.TitleLyricsLength
6."All Lovers Are Deranged"Townshend3:14
7."You Know I'm Right" 5:06
8."Cruise" 4:40
9."Let's Get Metaphysical"Instrumental4:09
10."Near the End" 5:36


Score: 4 

Roger Waters
The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking (April 1984)

First solo album by Roger Waters, released a month after Gilmour's second solo album. A rather leaden affair musically and lyrically. It's a story album - the theme being a man dreaming of hitch-hiking incidents. In the early part he appears to be driving in Europe and has sex with a hitch-hiker. After that it gets more vague, and he appears to be both driving in America and hitch-hiking. Throughout the dream his wife is present, and by the end he is happy she is there. It's not much of a story - there's nothing here I can relate to. Some of the blurring between reality and dream, and playful use of language and images I like, and there is potential in the idea, but it never really goes anywhere. Make of it what you will. Curious how much Eric Clapton sounds like Gilmore. Did Waters ask him to sound like Gilmore, or did Clapton assume Waters wanted that (or perhaps Clapton wanted to try to sound like Gilmore, who is, after all, a decent and distinctive guitarist). Anyway, I've given it a good try, and read the lyrics, and thought about it, and feel that there is a degree of ego and arrogance about this which  intrudes. Credit for the idea and the attempt, but it goes nowhere. Essentially, it doesn't work. But it's interesting. The title track is the best one - it is the only track that has any musical energy or strength. 


Released30 April 1984
RecordedFebruary–December 1983
Genre
Length42:07
Label
Producer

All tracks are written by Roger Waters[9].

No.TitleLength
1."4:30AM (Apparently They Were Travelling Abroad)"3:12
2."4:33AM (Running Shoes)"3:22
3."4:37AM (Arabs with Knives and West German Skies)"3:03
4."4:39AM (For the First Time Today, Part 2)"2:02
5."4:41AM (Sexual Revolution)"4:49
6."4:47AM (The Remains of Our Love)"3:09
Total length:19:37

Side two[edit]

No.TitleLength
1."4:50AM (Go Fishing)"6:59
2."4:56AM (For the First Time Today, Part 1)"1:38
3."4:58AM (Dunroamin, Duncarin, Dunlivin)"3:03
4."5:01AM (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking, Part 10)"4:36
5."5:06AM (Every Stranger's Eyes)"4:48
6."5:11AM (The Moment of Clarity)"1:28
Total length:22:32

Wikipedia
AllMusic: 8 
Score: 4 

Amid tension and legal battles, Gilmour records his next solo album as a Pink Floyd album with Wright and Mason. It's more pleasant and musical than Waters' Pink Floyd albums, but hardly the less trivial and self indulgent.



Released7 September 1987
RecordedNovember 1986 – March 1987
Studio
GenreProgressive rock
Length51:09
LabelEMI
Producer

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Signs of Life"
4:24
2."Learning to Fly"4:52
3."The Dogs of War"
  • Gilmour
  • Moore
6:10
4."One Slip"5:05
5."On the Turning Away"
  • Gilmour
  • Moore
5:42
6."Yet Another Movie"6:14
7."Round and Around" (instrumental)Gilmour1:13
8."A New Machine (Part 1)"Gilmour1:46
9."Terminal Frost" (instrumental)Gilmour6:17
10."A New Machine (Part 2)"Gilmour0:38
11."Sorrow"Gilmour8:47


Score: 3 

The best sounding Pink Floyd album since Wish You Were Here (1973), but it lacks heart and true ideas. Just a band going through the motions and raking in the money. 

Released28 March 1994
RecordedJanuary–December 1993
Studio
GenreProgressive rock[2]
Length66:23 (CD & 2014 LP)
58:47 (1994 LP)
LabelEMI
Producer

No.TitleLyricsMusicLength
1."Cluster One"instrumental5:56
2."What Do You Want from Me"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
4:22
3."Poles Apart"
Gilmour7:03
4."Marooned"instrumental
  • Wright
  • Gilmour
5:30
5."A Great Day for Freedom"
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
Gilmour4:16
6."Wearing the Inside Out"Anthony MooreWright6:49
7."Take It Back"
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
  • Laird-Clowes
6:12
8."Coming Back to Life"GilmourGilmour6:19
9."Keep Talking"
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
6:11
10."Lost for Words"
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
Gilmour5:15
11."High Hopes"
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
Gilmour8:31
Total length:66:23

  • David Gilmour – lead vocals, acoustic, electric, classical & steel guitars, bass guitar ("Poles Apart", "Wearing the Inside Out", "Lost for Words" and "High Hopes")
  • Nick Mason – drums, percussion, church bell
  • Richard Wright – keyboards, organ, synthesizers, lead vocals ("Wearing the Inside Out"), backing vocals

Additional musicians


Score: 3 1/2 

Pulse (1995) 

Live album. No great feel to it, and the song choices don't attract me. I prefer the studio versions. 


Released29 May 1995
Recorded17 August–29 October 1994
GenreProgressive rock
Length147:59
LabelEMI
Producer

Disc one
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I–V, VII" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)David Gilmour13:35
2."Astronomy Domine" (15 October 1994, Earls Court, London)Syd Barrett
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
4:20
3."What Do You Want From Me" (21 September 1994, Cinecittà, Rome)
Gilmour4:10
4."Learning to Fly" (14 October 1994, Earls Court, London)Gilmour5:16
5."Keep Talking" (17 August 1994, Niedersachsenstadion, Hanover)
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
  • Samson
Gilmour6:52
6."Coming Back to Life" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)GilmourGilmour6:56
7."Hey You" (13, 15 October 1994, Earls Court, London)WatersGilmour, Jon Carin4:40
8."A Great Day for Freedom" (19 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
Gilmour4:30
9."Sorrow" (20 September 1994, Cinecittà, Rome)GilmourGilmour10:49
10."High Hopes" (20, October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Samson
Gilmour7:52
11."Another Brick in the Wall, Part II" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)Waters
7:08
Total length:75:50
Disc two
No.TitleMusicLead vocalsLength
1."Speak to Me" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)Nick MasonInstrumental1:53
2."Breathe (In the Air)" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Gilmour
2:33
3."On the Run" (20, October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
Instrumental3:48
4."Time / Breathe (Reprise)" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Mason
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
6:47
5."The Great Gig in the Sky" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)5:52
6."Money" (17 September 1994, Modena)WatersGilmour8:54
7."Us and Them" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Waters
  • Wright
Gilmour6:58
8."Any Colour You Like" (19, 23 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
  • Mason
Instrumental3:21
9."Brain Damage" (19 October 1994, Earls Court, London)WatersGilmour3:46
10."Eclipse" (19 October 1994, Earls Court, London)WatersGilmour2:38
11."Wish You Were Here" (20 September 1994, Cinecittà, Rome)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
Gilmour6:35
12."Comfortably Numb" (20 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Wright
  • Gilmour
9:29
13."Run Like Hell" (15 October 1994, Earls Court, London)
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
  • Gilmour
  • Pratt
8:36
Total length:71:57

  • David Gilmour – lead vocals, lead guitar and lap steel guitar (on "One of These Days", "High Hopes" and "The Great Gig In the Sky")
  • Nick Mason – drums, percussion (on "Time")
  • Richard Wright – keyboards, backing vocals, lead vocals on "Astronomy Domine", co-lead vocals on "Time", "Us and Them" and "Comfortably Numb"

Score: 3 

 A huge overview compilation album. It ranges from the 1967 single "Arnold Layne" to the post-Water's 1994 album, The Division Bell. The bulk of the 26 tracks are from the Sixties and Seventies, with only seven tracks from their later period. The music is presented as a continuous flow (created by engineer/producer James Guthrie), rather than chronologically, giving a feel of a proper Floyd album rather than a Best Of, and gives an impressive summary of the band's work. The collection opens with what is arguably Floyd's best song, Barrett's "Astronomy Domine", which displays the whole band at their best, and sets the scene for what is to come - all the sounds and ideas here are the DNA for everything that follows. And as it was  the opening track for their debut album it seems appropriate for it to be the opening track for this summary of their entire career.

Good album. 


Disc one[edit]

No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Astronomy Domine" (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967))Barrett
4:10
2."See Emily Play" ("See Emily Play" single (1967), with an early cut-off; appears on 1971 Relics (1971), and 1967 US/Japan versions of The Piper at the Gates of Dawn)BarrettBarrett2:47
3."The Happiest Days of Our Lives" (The Wall (1979))WatersWaters1:38
4."Another Brick in the Wall (Part 2)" (The Wall)Waters4:01
5."Echoes" (Edited version; Meddle (1971))
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
16:30
6."Hey You" (The Wall)Waters
  • Gilmour
  • Waters
4:39
7."Marooned" (excerpt; The Division Bell (1994))
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
Instrumental2:02
8."The Great Gig in the Sky" (The Dark Side of the Moon (1973))Torry4:40
9."Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun" (A Saucerful of Secrets (1968))WatersWaters5:20
10."Money" (The Dark Side of the Moon)WatersGilmour6:29
11."Keep Talking" (Early fade-out; The Division Bell)
Gilmour5:57
12."Sheep" (Early fade-out; Animals (1977))WatersWaters9:46
13."Sorrow" (A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987))GilmourGilmour8:45
Total length:76:44

Disc two[edit]

No.TitleWriter(s)Lead vocalsLength
1."Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1–7)" (Edited version; Wish You Were Here (1975))Gilmour, Waters, WrightWaters17:32
2."Time" (includes "Breathe (In the Air) (Reprise)"); The Dark Side of the Moon)Gilmour, Waters, Wright, MasonGilmour, Wright6:48
3."The Fletcher Memorial Home" (The Final Cut (1983))WatersWaters4:07
4."Comfortably Numb" (includes the coda of "Bring the Boys Back Home"; The Wall)Gilmour, WatersGilmour, Waters6:53
5."When the Tigers Broke Free" (The Wall film soundtrack (1982), also on remasters of The Final Cut since 2004)WatersWaters3:42
6."One of These Days" (Meddle, edited version)Gilmour, Waters, Wright, MasonInstrumental, with spoken words by Mason5:15
7."Us and Them" (Edited ending, The Dark Side of the Moon)Waters, WrightGilmour, Wright7:51
8."Learning to Fly" (A Momentary Lapse of Reason)Gilmour, Anthony MooreBob EzrinJon CarinGilmour4:50
9."Arnold Layne" ("Arnold Layne" single (1967); appears on Relics)BarrettBarrett2:52
10."Wish You Were Here" (Early fade-out; Wish You Were Here)Gilmour, WatersGilmour5:21
11."Jugband Blues" (A Saucerful of Secrets)BarrettBarrett2:56
12."High Hopes" (Edited version; The Division Bell (1994))Gilmour, SamsonGilmour6:59
13."Bike" (with bell introThe Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967))BarrettBarrett3:24
Total length:78:30


Score: 6 


Quite modern and ambient, but also very pink Floyd. These are the extended instrumental pieces that have been at the heart of Floyd since 1966. The spirit of Syd's Floyd is here, and the thin, acid burning harshness of Water's Floyd is washed away. There is a feel of Dark Side here, This is, though, not great Floyd. It's the quiet bits in between the greatness all wrapped together into one album. It works, but it's not an essential Floyd album. It was created by working on tapes of music left over from the recording of The Division Bell when Wright was still alive (he died in 2008, 12 years after the making of Division Bell). A piece from 1969, Wright playing on the Albert Hall pipe organ, is incorporated into "Autumn 69". 

This will be the last ever Pink Floyd album (allegedly). 


No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Things Left Unsaid"4:26
2."It's What We Do"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
6:17
3."Ebb and Flow"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
1:55
4."Sum"
4:48
5."Skins"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
  • Mason
2:37
6."Unsung"Wright1:07
7."Anisina"Gilmour3:16
8."The Lost Art of Conversation"Wright1:42
9."On Noodle Street"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
1:42
10."Night Light"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
1:42
11."Allons-y (1)"Gilmour1:57
12."Autumn '68"Wright1:35
13."Allons-y (2)"Gilmour1:32
14."Talkin' Hawkin'"
  • Gilmour
  • Wright
3:29
15."Calling"3:37
16."Eyes to Pearls"Gilmour1:51
17."Surfacing"Gilmour2:46
18."Louder than Words"6:36
Total length:53:02

Score: 4 

 
(Box set)

Box set of assorted tracks, some live, some studio, mostly unreleased other than a few non-album singles. It's interesting rather than essential, and most of it would only appeal to hard core fans.  The first volume is the very early material with Syd Barrett from The Tea Set to Barrett's departure. It consists of three discs containing Tea Set demos, early Floyd singles, some live material, some BBC sessions, and some unreleased studio recordings. A fascinating collection. 

Volume 1: 1965–1967: Cambridge St/ation
Volume 2: 1968: Germin/ation
Volume 3: 1969: Dramatis/ation
Volume 4: 1970: Devi/ation
Volume 5: 1971: Reverber/ation
Volume 6: 1972: Obfusc/ation
Volume 7: 1967–1972: Continu/ation




AllMusic: 10 
Score: 5






Summary 

Voice/Musicianship (15)
There's no great singer in Floyd - they manage to get by, and Gilmour and Barrett sound OK, Waters less so; they are decent musicians, competent rather than interesting - Waters is an efficient bassist, while Gilmour is a fluid and reasonably attractive guitarist who is somewhat admired [10]
Image/Star quality (10)
As individuals they are not rock stars - Barrett was, but the rest of the band come across as accountants (or architects); however, as a band they have a special something due to their uniqueness, their bold creative approach, the sober, intellectual, and serious nature of their approach to the music, and their extraordinary success and reputation [9] 
Lyrics/Music (20)
Lyrics are not their strong point, though somehow the words work, especially on Dark Side; but the musical structures are stunning. [18]
Impact/Influence (10)
They have always attracted and held attention, and while there are no bands one can point to as being directly influenced by Floyd, their influence is there (especially Barrett's) [8]
Popularity (5)
One of the best selling artists of all time [5]
Emotional appeal (5)
For a band made up of architecture students who preferred jazz and classic music to blues and rock, they can at sublime moments, especially Dark Side, touch the soul [4]
Authenticity (25)
They always followed their own path, come what may. This was never a band led by commercial or popular appeal, or following the latest chart hitting trend. Full marks. [25]
Legacy (10)
They are giants in the music world, and always will be [10]
Total: 89/100

Discography



The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) - 10
A Saucerful of Secrets (1968) - 6
More (1969) - 7
Ummagumma (1969) - 5
Atom Heart Mother (1970) - 3
Meddle (1971) - 6
Obscured by Clouds (1972) - 3
The Dark Side of the Moon (1973) - 10
Wish You Were Here (1975) - 8
Animals (1977) - 2
The Wall (1979) - 2 1/2
The Final Cut (1983) - 1
A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987) - 3
The Division Bell (1994) - 3 1/2
The Endless River (2014) - 4



Albums by sales


 1. Dark Side of The Moon (1973)  50,000,000 
 2. The Wall (1979) 33,000,000 
 3. Wish You Were Here (1975) 23,000,000
 4. The Division Bell (1994)  12,000,000 
 5. Animals (1977) 6,500,000
 6. A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987)  5,800,000
 7. Echoes (2001) 5,500,000 
 8. Delicate Sound of Thunder (1988) 3,500,000
 9. The Final Cut (1983)  3,420,000
10 Pulse (1995)  3,400,000 
11 Meddle (1971) 3,100,000
12 The Endless River (2012)  2,500,000
13 A Collection of Great Dance Songs (1981) 2,260,000
14 UmmaGumma (1969) 1,500,000
15 Atom Heart Mother (1970) 1,300,000
16 Obscured By Clouds (1972)  785,000
17 A Nice Pair (1973) 712,000 
18 Is There Anybody Out There? (2000)  650,000
19 A Foot In The Door (2011)  525,000
20 Piper At The Gates Of Dawn (1967)   518,000 
21 Relics (1971)  379,000 
22 A Saucerful of Secrets (1968)  305,000 
23 Shine On (1992)  266,000 
24 More (1969) 262,000 
25 Works (1983)  261,000 
26 Masters Of Rock (1973)  100,000 
27 The Later Years (2019)  60,000 

Source: BSA 


Albums by ranking


The Dark Side of the Moon (1973) (10) - 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 9, 10, 10, 8, 10, 8, 
Wish You Were Here (1975) (8) - 8, 9, 9, 9, 9, 10, 8, 7, 10, 8, 9, 
The Wall (1979) (2 1/2) - 6, 8, 8, 8, 6, 1, 9, 9, 9, 9, 7, 
Animals (1977) (2) - 9, 7, 7, 7, 7, 5, 7, 8, 6, 6, 10, 
Meddle (1971) (6) - 7, 6, 5, 6, 8, 8, 6, 4, 7, 5, 6, 
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) (10) - 5, 5, 6, 5, 5, 7, 5, 2, 4, 7, 5, 
The Division Bell (1994) (3 1/2) - 1, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 6, 4, 2, 
Atom Heart Mother (1970) (3) - 2, 4, 2, 3, 4, 3, 1, 2, 3, 
A Saucerful of Secrets (1968) (6) - 2, 3, 2, 3, 1, 5, 3, 1, 4, 
The Final Cut (1983) (1) - 3, 1, 1, 1, 2,  2, 1, 5, 
Ummagumma (1969) (5) - 4, 2, 2, 
Obscured by Clouds (1972)  (3) - 1, 6, 1, 
More (1969) (7) - 3, 3, 
A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987) (3) - 3, 
The Endless River (2014) (4) - 


Songs/Tracks


1. Money 
2. Us and Them 
3. Time 
4. One of These Days 
5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond 
6. The Great Gig In The Sky 
7. On The Run 
8. Wish You Were Here 


Top rated songs

Wish You Were Here (Wish You Were Here, 1975) XXXV
Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-5) (Wish You Were Here, 1975) XXXI
Echoes (Meddle, 1971) XXX
Comfortably Numb (The Wall, 1979) XXVIIII 
Time (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) XXIII 
Us and Them (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) XXII
Another Brick in the Wall (Part 2) (The Wall, 1979) XX
Money (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) XX
Brain Damage/Eclipse (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) XVI
Dogs (Animals, 1977) XVI
The Great Gig in the Sky (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) XIIII
See Emily Play (Non-album single, 1967) XII
Astronomy Domine (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967) XI
Hey You (The Wall, 1979) VV
Interstellar Overdrive (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967)  VIIII
Breathe (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) VIII
Welcome to the Machine (Wish You Were Here, 1975) VII
One Of These Days (Meddle) VI 
Fearless (Meddle, 1971) VI
Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun (A Saucerful of Secrets, 1968) VI
Have A Cigar (Wish You Were Here, 1975) VI
Bike (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967) V
Arnold Layne (Non-album single, 1967) V
Careful with That Axe, Eugene (Ummagumma, 1969) V 
Sheep (Animals, 1977) V 
Run Like Hell (The Wall) IIII
Mother (The Wall) III
Lucifer Sam (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967) III
Goodbye Blue Sky (The Wall, 1979) III
High Hopes (The Division Bell, 1994) III
Pigs (Three Different Ones) (Animals)  II
When the Tigers Broke Free (Non-album single, 1982) II 
The Nile Song (More, 1969) I.
Atom Heart Mother (Atom Heart Mother, 1970) I
On the Run (The Dark Side of the Moon, 1973) I


Apples and Oranges (Non-album single, 1967)
Pow R. Toc H. (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967)
Scream Thy Last Scream (The Early Records 1965-1972, 2016)
Grantchester Meadows (Ummagumma, 1969)
Flaming (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967)
Walk with Me Sydney (The Early Records 1965-1972, 2016)
Louder Than Words (The Endless River, 2014)
Vegetable Man (The Early Records 1965-1972, 2016)
Explosion (The Early Records 1965-1972, 2016)
In the Flesh? (The Wall, 1979)
Wot’s... Uh the Deal? (Obscured by Clouds, 1972)
Jugband Blues (A Saucerful of Secrets, 1968)
Fat Old Sun (Atom Heart Mother, 1970)
Is There Anybody Out There? (The Wall, 1979)
Green Is the Colour (More, 1969)
Point Me at the Sky (Non-album single, 1968)
Paint Box (Non-album B side, 1967)
Matilda Mother (The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, 1967)
Remember a Day (A Saucerful of Secrets, 1968)
Quicksilver (More, 1969)
Young Lust 
Learning To Fly I 
One of These Days 
What Do You Want From Me? 
Free Four 
Vera 
The Show Must Go On 
Nobody Home 


* Reddit 
* Ranker 
* Stereogum  

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments welcome